British Archaeology banner

Cover of British Archaeology

Issue 77

July 2004

Contents

news

Coins find could test ancient monuments law

Restoration 2

Pipes may be oldest wooden musical instrument

Medieval quay found

Henge update

Roman graves and mosaics in danger

In Brief

features

Black wall
Richard Benjamin has a special interest in Hadrian's Wall

White man
Martin Bell and Ronald Hutton on the Wilmington mystery

For the children
Jo Catling and Towse Harrison find archaeology can inspire

Must-have accessories
Justine Bayley and Sarnia Butcher on a major Roman study

letters

Roman fort, teeth,place names and Prittlewell kings

opinion

Emma Restall Orr wants a spiritual side to archaeology

spoilheap

Neil Mortimer prepares Lycra battle with English Heritage

books

Bronze & the Bronze Age: Metalwork & Society in Britain c 2500-800 BC by Martyn Barber

Medieval Archaeology: Understanding Traditions & Contemporary Approaches by Christopher Gerrard

Voices in the Past: English Literature & Archaeology by John Hines

Excavations on Copa Hill, Cwmystwyth (1986-1999) by Simon Timberlake

Fiskerton.
An Iron Age Timber Causeway with Iron Age & Roman Votive Offerings by Naomi Field & Mike Parker Pearson

Roman Carmarthen: Excavations 1978-1993 by Heather James

TRAC 2002: Proceedings of the 12th Annual Theoretical Roman Archaeology Conference, Canterbury by Gillian Carr, Ellen Swift & Jake Weekes

Medieval Building Techniques by Günther Binding, trans Alex Cameron

Monastic Landscapes by James Bond

The Archaeology of Reformation by David Gaimster & Roberta Gilchrist

Barley, Malt & Ale in the Neolithic by Merryn Dineley

The Archaeology of Twentieth Century Tameside by Michael Nevell & John Walker

CBA update

tv in ba

Columnists find Time Team harder than it looks

science

Chief archaeological scientist Sebastian Payne's new column

my archaeology

Philip Beale left his job for an archaeological experiment

 

ISSN 1357-4442

Editor Mike Pitts

science

For understanding our shared past

In his first regular column Sebastian Payne, chief scientist at English Heritage, seeks a balance in approaches to ancient human remains

New ways of analysing human remains are helping us understand the past. Ancient DNA makes news but other techniques deliver at a fraction of the cost. Nitrogen and carbon isotope ratios in human bone collagen, for instance, tell us about diet. Oxygen isotope ratios in bone and tooth minerals reflect rainwater, and strontium isotopes local geology, marking skeletons according to where people lived or grew up.

Recent work on stable isotope ratios in teeth suggests greater mobility in Medieval England than in Iron Age or Roman times: one in six at the Early Medieval village of West Heslerton, Yorkshire may have been first-generation immigrants from across the North Sea.¹ The Early Bronze Age ‘Amesbury Archer’ was also born on the continent. As with any new approach, there are uncertainties (contrary to reports, the Archer’s home could not be pinned down to as small a region as Switzerland), but of particular value is that methods like this bring out variation at the personal level – real people with individual histories.

Another new technique, looking at bone density, shows that osteoporosis was as common among older women in the now deserted Medieval village of Wharram Percy, Yorkshire as it is today, casting doubt on suggestions that osteoporosis is caused by modern life-style.² Such studies have obvious potential value for modern medicine.

We need to be able to return to material from old excavations: these techniques were not available when most of the sites were excavated. Yet museums can be reluctant to keep large collections of human remains,³ and the Church of England usually requires reburial after excavation in places under their jurisdiction. It then becomes almost impossible to apply new methods.

An English Heritage and Church of England working group recommends that important groups of skeletons should, if possible, be kept accessible.&sup4; Storage in redundant churches and crypts is proposed, thus keeping remains in consecrated ground. This is surely to be welcomed.

Other proposals could be more problematic. DCMS is about to seek comments on the Palmer report on the repatriation of human remains in Britain’s museums. It is clearly right that these be returned to close family if they request them. This is current practice here, as happened with Louisa Courtauld, buried in Spitalfields in 1807. After excavation, her remains were reburied at her family’s wishes.

For older remains, however, a balance must be drawn. In a long dispute, four Native American tribes seek to prevent scientific examination of Kennewick Man, a 10,000 year old skeleton from the western USA. Here the claimed relationship and rights seem very tenuous. The balance should favour scientific examination of a skeleton important for understanding the early colonisation of America.

The new Human Tissue Bill allows national museums to de-accession and repatriate human remains.&sup5; It would also make it illegal to examine or possess human remains without a licence, understandable after Alder Hey, where children’s organs were removed without parents’ consent. Unlike museums, archaeologists would not be exempt, although we already have licensing and reporting procedures to control excavation. There was no consultation during the drafting of the bill. It should be amended so that licensing is required only for recent remains, perhaps less than 100 years old.

The study of human remains is poised to deliver exciting new insights. It is vital that collections remain accessible for future study and that we avoid unneeded bureaucracy and cost. We must treat human remains with respect, and give strong weight to the views of close relatives. But we must never forget the importance of greater understanding of our shared past.

More science

1 Antiquity 2004, p127
2 International Journal of Osteoarchaeology 1998, p97
3 Times 6 January 2004
4 www.english-heritage.org.uk/archaeology/consultationdocuments
5 www.parliament.the-stationery-office.co.uk/pa/cm200304/cmbills/009/2004009.htm

CBA web:

British Archaeology

Jan/Feb 2005
Mar/Apr 2005
May/Jun 2005
Jul/Aug 2005
Sep/Oct 2005
Nov/Dec 2005
Jan/Feb 2006
Mar/Apr 2006
May/Jun 2006
Jul/Aug 2006
Sep/Oct 2006
Nov/Dec 2006
Jan/Feb 2007
Mar/Apr 2007
May/Jun 2007
Jul/Aug 2007
Sep/Oct 2007
Nov/Dec 2007
Jan/Feb 2008
Mar/Apr 2008
May/Jun 2008
Jul/Aug 2008
Sep/Oct 2008
Nov/Dec 2008
Jan/Feb 2009
Mar/Apr 2009
May/Jun 2009
Jul/Aug 2009
Sep/Oct 2009
Nov/Dec 2009
Jan/Feb 2010
Mar/Apr 2010
May/Jun 2010
Jul/Aug 2010
Sep/Oct 2010
Nov/Dec 2010
Jan/Feb 2011
Mar/Apr 2011
May/Jun 2011
Jul/Aug 2011
Sep/Oct 2011
Nov/Dec 2011
Jan/Feb 2012
Mar/Apr 2012

CBA Briefing

Fieldwork
Conferences
Noticeboard
Courses & lectures
CBA Network
Grants & awards

CBA homepage